Computerised German law/TakeLaw-System

Amazing electronic developments in Wismar:

bq. Wenn am 2. November 2005 der Justizminister des Landes Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Erwin Sellering, im modernen Technologiezentrum in Wismar das TakeLaw-System eröffnet, dann könnte für die Welt der Rechtswissenschaft ein neues Zeitalter anbrechen. … Es geht darum, die oft unverständliche Sprache der Juristen in eine computergenerierte graphische Darstellungsform zu übersetzen. Diese Kunstsprache ist für die Rechtswissenschaft mit einem Kunstherz in der Medizin vergleichbar: Es sorgt dafür, dass der juristische Gedanke auch dann am Leben bleibt, wenn der eigentliche Motor der Rechtswissenschaft – die Fachsprache –nicht mehr verständlich ist. Die erforderliche Software dafür, der TakeLaw-Editor, wird ab dem 2. November 2005 über das Internet für jedermann frei zur Verfügung stehen (www.TakeLaw.de).

I will have to see this to have any idea what it means. Apparently software (freely available to all after November 2 on a site that at present offers nothing) will convert legal language by computer into a graphic form. This is compared with an artificial heart, because legal ideas remain alive even when the ‘real engine of jurisprudence, legal jargon,’ is no longer comprehensible.

What is more, it will enable automatic marking of tests:

bq. Nunmehr wird es möglich sein, juristische Übungsklausuren computergesteuert zu korrigieren. Die Korrektur ist mit einer ausführlichen Besprechung sofort verfügbar. Dazu vergleicht das System das Ergebnis der abgegebenen Arbeit mit der erwarteten Lösung und erläutert es dem Studenten. Dabei werden ihm nicht nur seine Fehler aufgezeigt, sondern auch die richtige Lösung über Lautsprecher oder Kopfhörer mitgeteilt. Gleichzeitig erkennt das TakeLaw-System Wissenslücken und stellt entsprechende multimediale Vorlesungen über das Internet zur Verfügung. Diese werden derzeit in Wismar in einem Tonstudio von insgesamt 12 Rechtsdozenten aus 9 Universitäten produziert.

bq. It will now be possible to mark legal tests electronically. The corrected version will be available immediately with a detailed discussion. This is produced by the system comparing the test submitted with the correct solution and explaining it to the student. The student is not only shown the errors – the correct version is also given, by loudspeaker or headphones. The TakeLaw system at the same time spots gaps in knowledge and provides multi-media lectures via Internet. These are being recorded now by a total of 12 law lecturers from 9 universities at a studio in Wismar.

All this sounds almost as difficult as machine translation. I imagine they can do multiple-choice questions online, and then supplement gaps in the person’s knowledge as seen by the system. But how can they translate legal jargon into graphics?

(Via Handakte WebLAWg)

Prohibited degrees in Warrington / Schwiegermutter heiraten

BBC News reports

bq. The European Court of Human Rights earlier this month ruled the ban on marriage between people who were in-laws is a breach of human rights.
The decision came in a case brought by a man and his daughter-in-law.
Coincidentally, that couple were also from Warrington.

The Times still has an article on the Strasbourg case online.

bq. The court was told that a son from the woman’s first marriage now calls his own grandfather “Dad” and that the couple plans to adopt him. The man and woman went to the European Court of Human Rights after being refused permission to marry by the Superintendent Registrar at Warrington Register Office.

Private Acts of parliament have sometimes been passed, but the last was apparently in 1987. One assumes the law will be changed – there have occasionally been remarks suggesting it is pointless.

European Court of Human Rights, Case of B. and L. v. The United Kingdom

Extraordinary rendition

The World Wide Words newsletter, whose RSS feed I read, has chosen the term extraordinary rendition to comment on.

In US law rendition refers to the transfer of individuals by what is called extra-judicial process (kidnapping, in plain speech) from a foreign country to the USA to answer criminal charges. The defendant is said to have been rendered up to justice.
A problem for the security forces is that once brought to the USA the person is subject to US law and the rules of due process, which of course excludes torture. Hence extraordinary rendition, a euphemism for taking them to a country where these rules do not apply.
From the Independent, 1 Jul. 2005: One week ago a judge in Milan signed warrants for the arrest of 13 of the agents, which has thrown covert CIA activities outside the US under the spotlight and drawn attention to the increasingly common practice of so-called ‘extraordinary rendition’, by which the US seizes terror suspects and removes them to countries known for their use of torture.

Außergewöhnliche Auslieferung, I suppose. Here’s a German article of June 2005 using that term:

Italien: Erstmals geht Justiz in Europa gegen US-Praktiken des Kidnappings Verdächtiger vor. Klarnamen von Geheimdienstagenten an Mailänder Konsulat aufgedeckt

The terms Kidnapping and Verschleppung seem to be more common. See heise.de.
For rendition, Romain has ‘Überstellung von Straftätern (ohne förmliche Auslieferung)’.

Wikipedia has something about it too.

Miscellaneous links / Links, vermischt

Today is European Languages Day, as I have mentioned sporadically since 2003, but it must have been going on longer than that. There is a game where you have to pinpoint on the map where each of the 41 languages of Europe is an official language. I managed 6 places with German and 3 with English, and I could do Azerbaidjan, Albania and Armenia, but although I recognize a Slavic language when I see one, there seem very many places to put it. There are the words for ‘Talk to me’ in all the languages – but even afterwards, they didn’t say what the language is called, or did I miss something?
LATER NOTE: I see Linklogbuch says the quiz doesn’t work in Firefox, but it does in Opera. What does it do that it doesn’t do in Firefox – give you a prize? I just had a look at it in IE, but there was no difference in playing. But surely German is an official language in part of Italy, isn’t it?

Today is also, according to the news, the first day for some well-known people (but not politicians) to say ‘Du bist das Wunder von Deutschland’ (You are the miracle of Germany). In fact, something will be happening at this website at 19.45 CET. It was strange enough seeing all the TV ads for Baden-Württemberg (‘We can do everything except speak High German’), but this should be weirder. I hope they have someone in the line-up who says ‘Church and state really are divided, despite appearances!’

The Language Guy examines four theories as to why President Bush sometimes mangles his words, and comes down on the side of the least offensive of them, namely mild anomia, a kind of verbal disorder.